Nadler’s departure opens up a key Democratic seat for the first time in decades, prompting a competitive race among local officials and political operatives. As chair of the House Judiciary Committee during Donald Trump’s first impeachment, Nadler held significant influence in Congress. His retirement, he said, was reinforced by President Biden’s decision not to seek reelection, adding that younger leadership is needed to confront today’s political challenges.

The vacancy is expected to attract a crowded field, with political veterans and newcomers alike eyeing the seat. The 12th District, which includes parts of Manhattan, is a heavily Democratic stronghold, making the primary contest particularly crucial. With the Democratic establishment searching for a fresh yet electable candidate, Clinton’s name serves as a powerful reminder of legacy and recognition in national politics.

While rumors of Chelsea Clinton’s candidacy have persisted for years, she has consistently denied interest. In past interviews, she emphasized advocacy over politics, telling Variety in 2017, “I am not running for office.” Unless she changes course, the battle for NY-12 will likely be between longtime Democratic insiders vying for a rare open seat in a solidly blue district.

Nadler has not endorsed a successor but expressed hope that new leadership would bring energy and fresh ideas. He pledged to stay active in public life after stepping down in 2026, stating his commitment to defending democracy and the values he has long championed. For now, Democrats are left to navigate a high-stakes primary with no clear frontrunner.